Best Real Estate Agents in Columbus, OH — 2026 Rankings
We ranked 25 real estate agents in Columbus based on credentials, client reviews, press recognition, and experience.
Top Real Estate Agents in Columbus
-
#1 — J. Waller Commercial Real Estate Score: 55/100
J. Waller Commercial Real Estate — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#2 — Karen Smith at Keller Williams Capital Partners Score: 51/100
Karen Smith at Keller Williams Capital Partners — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: General. View full profile →
-
#3 — Joseph Skillen & Company Score: 32/100
Joseph Skillen & Company — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#4 — Trent Ecklar Real Estate Team Score: 22/100
Trent Ecklar Real Estate Team — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#5 — Vutech Ruff Score: 22/100
Vutech Ruff — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#6 — University Village Score: 21/100
University Village — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#7 — Mike Ferris Properties Score: 19/100
Mike Ferris Properties — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#8 — Recrafted Real Estate Score: 19/100
Recrafted Real Estate — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#9 — 1717 Canvasback Ln, Columbus, OH 43215 Score: 19/100
1717 Canvasback Ln, Columbus, OH 43215 — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#10 — Inn-Town Homes & Apartments Score: 18/100
Inn-Town Homes & Apartments — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#11 — Dunkel Company Score: 17/100
Dunkel Company — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#12 — NorthSteppe Realty Score: 17/100
NorthSteppe Realty — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#13 — Cutler Real Estate Score: 17/100
Cutler Real Estate — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#14 — Brugge Properties Score: 16/100
Brugge Properties — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#15 — Cap City Title Agency Score: 15/100
Cap City Title Agency — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#16 — Panzera Realty Score: 15/100
Panzera Realty — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#17 — The Land Bank Center Score: 15/100
The Land Bank Center — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#18 — Havenwood Townhomes Score: 14/100
Havenwood Townhomes — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#19 — RE/MAX City Center Realtors Score: 14/100
RE/MAX City Center Realtors — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#20 — The New Victorians Score: 14/100
The New Victorians — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#21 — Coldwell Banker Score: 14/100
Coldwell Banker — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#22 — Terra Maven Group Score: 14/100
Terra Maven Group — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#23 — Ned Merkle & Company Realtors Score: 14/100
Ned Merkle & Company Realtors — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#24 — RE/MAX Metro Plus Score: 14/100
RE/MAX Metro Plus — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes. View full profile →
-
#25 — Manchester Townhomes Rental Office Score: 6/100
Manchester Townhomes Rental Office — Real Estate in Columbus, OH
Services: Luxury Homes, Investment Property. View full profile →
How We Rank Real Estate Agents
Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google reviews (25%), professional credentials like CRS, ABR, GRI, SRES, CCIM certification (20%), press recognition (15%), review volume (15%), web and portfolio presence (10%), years of experience (10%), and profile completeness (5%). Read our full methodology →
Frequently asked questions
- Who is the #1 real estate agent in Columbus?
- J. Waller Commercial Real Estate is currently the #1 ranked real estate agent in Columbus based on our Guide Score, which evaluates Google reviews, credentials, press recognition, and experience. See the full ranked list above.
- How are real estate agents ranked in Columbus?
- Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google reviews (25%), professional credentials like CRS/ABR/GRI (20%), press recognition (15%), review volume (15%), web presence (10%), years of experience (10%), and profile completeness (5%). There is no paid placement.
- What real estate services are most common in Columbus?
- The most common service specialties among Columbus agents in our directory are luxury homes, investment property.